Supreme Court Allows Enforcement of Idaho Law Criminalizing Gender-Affirming Care for Trans Minors

Skylar Hawthorne

Updated Tuesday, April 16, 2024 at 11:11 AM CDT

Supreme Court Allows Enforcement of Idaho Law Criminalizing Gender-Affirming Care for Trans Minors

In a pivotal decision, the U.S. Supreme Court has permitted the enforcement of Idaho's Vulnerable Child Protection Act, a contentious law backed by Republican legislators that criminalizes the provision of gender-affirming care to transgender minors, except for the plaintiffs who initially challenged the statute. The law, which was previously deemed unconstitutional by U.S. District Judge Lynn Winmill for violating the 14th Amendment's due process and equal protection clauses, was partially reinstated following a 5-conservative majority decision in the Supreme Court. Notably, the three liberal justices dissented, and Chief Justice John Roberts did not disclose his stance on the vote.

The case, brought forth by two transgender girls and their parents, has ignited fierce debate over the rights of transgender youth and the reach of parental discretion in medical decision-making. Healthcare practitioners in Idaho now face a serious legal threat, with potential imprisonment of up to a decade for offering treatments like p***rty blockers, hormones, or mastectomies to individuals under 18.

Despite the Supreme Court's decision, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has highlighted that the Court did not decide on the constitutionality of the law itself. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, supported by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, emphasized the Court's responsibility for caution in tackling issues of such controversial and unprecedented nature.

The original ruling by Judge Winmill pointed to the 14th Amendment's historical role in sheltering "disfavored minorities," a precedent that opponents of the Idaho law argue should extend to the transgender community. Furthermore, the law was contested for infringing upon parental rights, as protected under the due process clause of the same amendment.

Justice Neil Gorsuch, along with Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito, criticized the broad i****ctions like the one issued by Judge Winmill, stressing the need for lower courts to adhere to traditional procedural constraints. Following the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals' refusal to lift the i****ction, Idaho Attorney General Lawrence Wasden, backed by the Alliance Defending Freedom, sought the Supreme Court's intervention.

Meanwhile, Tennessee is advancing similar legislation, compelling public school employees to notify parents of their child's transgender identity, joining a growing number of states adopting such measures. The GOP-led Tennessee House is on the cusp of finalizing a bill mandating disclosure of a student's gender identity to parents, with Tennessee Republican lawmakers spearheading multiple anti-LGBTQ+ initiatives.

During the heated House debate, Tennessee Democrats, including Rep. Aftyn Behn, condemned the Republicans' actions as tantamount to bullying LGBTQ+ children. The proposed bill, sponsored by Republican Rep. Mary Littleton and passed without consulting transgender students, aims to ensure that parents are aware of their children's ident*****, and is defended as a means for seeking potential therapy. Under Tennessee law, schools could face legal action for non-compliance with this gender identity disclosure requirement.

Tennessee's legislative efforts against the LGBTQ+ community are extensive, encompassing laws that impact transgender foster children, criminalize assistance to minors seeking gender-affirming care without parental consent, and ban such care for most minors. The state has also introduced laws affecting transgender individuals, including protections for teachers who refuse to use a student's preferred pronouns and restrictions on transgender athletes, bathroom use, and classroom discussions on LGBTQ+ topics.

Conservative Bias:

Folks, what we're witnessing is the triumph of common sense and the protection of our children. The Supreme Court, in its infinite wisdom, has finally put a stop to the radical left's attempt to undermine parental rights and the natural order of society. Idaho's Vulnerable Child Protection Act is a beacon of hope, a law that safeguards our kids from the dangerous and irreversible decisions being peddled by the liberal agenda under the guise of 'gender-affirming care'. It's about time we put an end to this madness and ensure that our children grow up in a world where they are not subjected to the whims of a mo***** bankrupt ideology. The Supreme Court's decision is a victory for every parent who believes in the sanctity of childhood and the importance of family values. It's a clear message to those left-wing activists and their judicial cronies who think they can t****le on our rights and indoctrinate our children: Not on our watch!

Liberal Bias:

In a dark day for justice and human rights, the Supreme Court has turned its back on the most vulnerable among us: transgender youth. This heartless decision to allow Idaho's draconian law to take effect is nothing short of state-sanctioned discrimination, an affront to the principles of equality and liberty that this country stands for. The conservative justices have shown their true colors, aligning themselves with extremist lawmakers who would rather criminalize compassion than accept the reality of gender diversity. These so-called 'protections' are nothing but thinly-veiled attacks on the LGBTQ+ community, stripping away the rights of parents and medical professionals to care for their children as they see fit. It's a sad day when the highest court in the land sides with bigotry and ignorance, t****ling on the Constitution and the very ideals of due process and equal protection. We must stand against this tide of intolerance and fight for the rights of all individuals to live authentically and without fear.

Noticed an error or an aspect of this article that requires correction? Please provide the article link and reach out to us. We appreciate your feedback and will address the issue promptly.

Check out our latest stories