The Rise of the Hole Punch: A Controversial Design Choice in Modern Smartphones

Logan Anderson

Updated Tuesday, March 5, 2024 at 4:43 PM CDT

The Rise of the Hole Punch: A Controversial Design Choice in Modern Smartphones

The Evolution of Smartphone Design

The modern smartphone design includes a hole in the top middle or top left of the screen for the selfie camera, or in the case of iPhones, an entire notch. This design choice allows the screen bezels to stretch out further and evenly fill the screen, potentially increasing the claimed size of the phone screen. The presence of a hole punch or notch on the screen has become the norm in flagship modern phones.

A Questionable Design Norm

But how did people allow this design to become the norm? Some may argue that having a top bezel does not take away from viewing pleasure, as it is outside of the screen and not visible during content consumption. However, others question this design choice, comparing it to buying a TV with a dead spot on the screen. Moving the selfie camera inside the screen creates the perception of a damaged screen with a cluster of dead pixels, which is seen constantly when viewing content.

The Downside of the Notch

Many users consider this design choice a massive downgrade compared to having a small bezel at the top of the phone. Additionally, the acceptance of notches on laptop screens may indicate that people do not mind having a portion of the screen missing. However, there are those who prefer the hole punch design, as it utilizes the "unused" space at the top of the screen and makes the screen slightly bigger. For them, this design is a win-win situation.

A Matter of Personal Preference

Opinions on smartphone design vary greatly. Some agree with the notion that the hole punch design is distracting and takes away from the overall user experience. Others, like the author, appreciate the slight curves and find the design reminiscent of video game aesthetics. There are also those who have grown accustomed to hole punches on their phones and find them acceptable, while disliking notches and dynamic islands from Apple due to their noticeable nature.

The Future of Smartphone Design

It is worth noting that the hole punch design is seen by many as a stop-gap solution until a better way to integrate the front-facing camera under the screen is found. The compromise of having even bezels around the screen is seen as a decent solution for now. However, as smartphone design continues to evolve, it is important to consider the disappearance of other features such as SD card slots, headphone jacks, physical fingerprint scanners, IR blasters, and distinctive designs. These changes are seen by some as further downgrades in smartphone design.

The rise of the hole punch design in modern smartphones has sparked controversy among users. While some appreciate the increased screen real estate, others find it distracting and reminiscent of a damaged screen. As smartphone design continues to evolve, it remains to be seen what the future holds for front-facing camera integration and the overall user experience.

Noticed an error or an aspect of this article that requires correction? Please provide the article link and reach out to us. We appreciate your feedback and will address the issue promptly.

Check out our latest stories