The Battle of Carry-On vs Checked Baggage: To Charge or Not to Charge?

Lily Smith

Updated Saturday, December 16, 2023 at 7:39 AM CDT

The Battle of Carry-On vs Checked Baggage: To Charge or Not to Charge?

The Frustration of Excessive Carry-On Luggage

Flying has become a common mode of transportation for many, with people taking to the skies more frequently than ever before. However, there is a growing frustration among frequent flyers regarding the issue of carry-on luggage. The author of a popular Reddit post shares their exasperation with individuals who bring too much carry-on baggage, causing delays and inconvenience for everyone involved.

In the post, the author suggests that airlines should implement a system where carry-on bags are charged, while checked bags are free. This, they argue, would encourage people to check their luggage and reduce the amount of overhead bin space taken up by oversized carry-ons.

One point raised by the author is that those who complain about lost luggage are often infrequent flyers who choose to travel during winter storms. They believe that these individuals should bear the responsibility of checking their bags to avoid any potential mishaps.

To address the issue of excessive carry-on luggage, the author proposes that carry-on bags should only contain essential items such as a change of clothes, toiletries, medicine, electronics, chargers, a book, snack, and water bottle. Everything else, they argue, should be checked, as there is no need to carry an excessive amount of underwear or non-essential items in a carry-on bag.

Moreover, the author emphasizes the importance of properly packing a carry-on bag with essential items. They suggest that if luggage does get lost, having these essentials allows for easier shopping for new items using airline or insurance coverage.

The idea of charging for carry-on bags while making checked baggage free is reiterated by the author. They believe that more people would opt to check their baggage if it came at no additional cost and if insurance coverage was provided in case of loss or damage.

However, not everyone agrees with the original author's perspective. Another Reddit user argues that they prefer using a carry-on bag to avoid being separated from their computer and medication, regardless of weather conditions. They point out that pilots and airplane staff also rely on carry-on bags and personal items.

Furthermore, it is highlighted that some individuals may have specific medical conditions that require them to carry large amounts of medication or medical devices. For them, checking these items may not be a viable option.

On the other hand, there are individuals who prefer to travel light and avoid checking baggage altogether. They pack accordingly based on the length of their trip and the availability of laundry facilities at their destination.

While some express reluctance to check their laptop and clothing underneath the plane due to the risk of loss, others argue that the trend of carrying all luggage onboard began when airlines started charging for checked bags. This, in turn, resulted in longer wait times to deplane.

The debate surrounding carry-on and checked baggage fees reveals conflicting opinions. Some advocate for stricter regulations to prevent excessive carry-on luggage, while others argue for free checked bags to incentivize travelers to check their baggage. Finding a balance that satisfies both parties remains a challenge for airlines and passengers alike.

the battle between carry-on and checked baggage fees continues to spark heated discussions among frequent flyers. While some argue for charging for carry-on bags and providing free checked baggage, others advocate for the importance of personal items and medical necessities in carry-ons. Striking a balance that ensures a smooth travel experience for all remains a goal worth pursuing.

Noticed an error or an aspect of this article that requires correction? Please provide the article link and reach out to us. We appreciate your feedback and will address the issue promptly.

Check out our latest stories