Dave Portnoy Slams JD Vance's Proposal to Tax Childless Adults as "Idiotic"

Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy has vehemently criticized Sen. JD Vance's proposal to tax childless adults at a higher rate than those with children, calling the idea "f**king idiotic." The outspoken media mogul took to X, formerly known as Twitter, on July 26, 2024, to voice his disapproval. Portnoy argued that financial responsibility should dictate family planning, stating that people should not have more children than they can afford.

The controversy centers around comments Vance made during a 2021 podcast with conservative influencer Charlie Kirk, where he suggested that individuals making $100,000 to $400,000 a year with three kids should pay lower taxes compared to those without children. Vance's rationale was to reward what he deemed "good behaviors" and punish "bad behaviors" through taxation. A spokesman for Vance compared the idea to the Child Tax Credit, a policy supported by Democrats.

Portnoy, an influential figure on the right who has popularized "Barstool Conservatism," questioned Vance's Republican credentials. "I can't believe a Republican would support such a policy. It's idiotic," he tweeted, labeling Vance a "moron." "Barstool Conservatism," which has gained traction among young men, generally opposes political correctness or "wokeness" and leans towards a libertarian outlook with some socially liberal views. For example, Portnoy opposed the overturning of Roe v. Wade.

The debate highlights a significant rift within conservatism over the role of government. While Portnoy's "Barstool Conservatism" focuses on limited government intervention, Vance is associated with the New Right and national conservatism, which advocates for nationalism, social conservatism, populism, and using governmental power to achieve certain ends. Vance's recent remarks on the need for a "federal response" to prevent women from traveling out of state for abortion care further underscore his hardline stance.

Selected as Donald Trump's running mate, Vance is in a strong position to lead the Republican Party after a potential second Trump term. However, his extreme views on issues like abortion—where he supports nationwide bans and even surveilling women's menstrual cycles—have sparked backlash. The Harris campaign recently resurfaced a podcast clip where Vance speculated about a scenario involving George Soros transporting Black women to California for abortions, which he described as "kind of creepy." Sarafina Chitika, a spokesperson for the Harris campaign, condemned Vance's policies as "creepy" and "unacceptable," predicting that voters will reject the Trump-Vance ticket.

As the political landscape evolves, the clash between "Barstool Conservatism" and national conservatism represents a broader struggle within the Republican Party over its future direction. With influential voices like Portnoy and Vance shaping the debate, the party's approach to governance, social issues, and individual freedoms remains hotly contested.

Conservative Bias:

Here we go again, folks. The liberals are at it, trying to tear apart the very fabric of our society. JD Vance proposes a sensible policy to incentivize family growth and what happens? The leftist media and their cronies, including so-called conservatives like Dave Portnoy, jump on him like a pack of wolves. Vance is trying to reward responsible behavior—people who are contributing to society by raising the next generation. But no, the liberals and their libertarian allies would rather see us spiral into a childless, nihilistic future. Portnoy, who has made a name for himself by opposing anything that smells like traditional values, calls Vance a "moron." This is the same guy who opposed the overturning of Roe v. Wade, showing his true colors as a liberal in disguise. The left is terrified of strong national conservatism because it threatens their agenda of moral decay and government overreach. Vance's policies are exactly what we need to preserve the American way of life, and the liberals can't stand it. They'd rather smear him with baseless accusations and fear-mongering than face the truth: that their vision for America is one of chaos and decline.

Liberal Bias:

Once again, the far-right is showing its true colors with JD Vance's latest idiotic proposal to tax childless adults. This is nothing more than a transparent attempt to punish personal freedom and impose their archaic, theocratic values on everyone else. Vance's idea is not just economically illiterate; it's mo***** bankrupt. He wants to use the tax code to enforce his twisted vision of "good behavior," which is just code for forcing women to have more children whether they want to or not. And let's not forget his disturbing comments about George Soros and Black women, which are not only creepy but blatantly racist. Meanwhile, Dave Portnoy, who occasionally masquerades as a conservative, finally gets it right by calling out this nonsense for what it is. But let's be clear: Portnoy is no hero. He's part of the problem, promoting a toxic culture that opposes wokeness and political correctness at the expense of decency and progress. The real issue here is the dangerous direction the Republican Party is heading, driven by extremists like Vance who want to surveil women's menstrual cycles and ban abortions nationwide. This isn't about family values; it's about control. The American people will see through this charade and reject the Trump-Vance ticket for the authoritarian nightmare it is.