The Flaws of Interview Questions

Harper Quill

Updated Sunday, October 29, 2023 at 10:50 PM CDT

The Flaws of Interview Questions

Unveiling the Truth Behind Interview Questions

Interviews have long been a standard part of the hiring process, but many job seekers question their effectiveness. Reddit user BillyJayJersey505 expressed frustration with interview questions, claiming that they often favor those who can lie or b******* their way through. They argue that interview questions are biased towards extroverted individuals who are more well-spoken. While this sentiment may resonate with some, it is essential to understand the purpose and limitations of interview questions.

Assessing Personal Opinion: A Valid Approach?

One aspect of interviews that BillyJayJersey505 found particularly objectionable was the inclusion of questions about personal opinion. They argue that questions like, "Do you prefer parachuting from a plane or planting flowers?" are irrelevant to job performance and should be illegal. While it may seem odd to ask such questions, they can serve a purpose.

Employers often use these questions to assess a candidate's thought process, problem-solving skills, and ability to think on their feet. The specific answer is not as crucial as the candidate's ability to articulate their reasoning behind it. These questions can provide insights into a candidate's personality, creativity, and decision-making abilities, which may be relevant to certain roles.

The Truth Behind Interview Questions

The comments from Reddit users jsbe and MalibuStasi shed light on the rationale behind interview questions. Jsbe argues that interviews are primarily about assessing whether a candidate is "normal" and can interact comfortably with coworkers and customers. Hiring managers seek individuals who can fit seamlessly into the company culture and maintain positive relationships.

MalibuStasi adds that interviews go beyond evaluating technical skills. They assess a candidate's critical thinking abilities, interpersonal skills, and how they handle unexpected situations. Companies want to ensure that a potential employee will not disrupt the workplace or pose a risk to customer relations. While technical skills are important, companies prioritize hiring individuals who align with the company's values and can contribute positively to the team.

The Importance of Authenticity

While interview questions may seem flawed to some, it is crucial for candidates to approach them with authenticity. BillyJayJersey505's comment about being "too truthful" highlights the delicate balance between honesty and presenting oneself in the best light. It is essential to find a middle ground where candidates can showcase their true selves while also demonstrating their suitability for the role.

Authenticity is key because companies are not just hiring a set of skills; they are hiring a person. Employers want to gauge how candidates handle interpersonal and social situations, as these skills are vital in maintaining a harmonious work environment. By being genuine and prepared, candidates can increase their chances of making a positive impression during an interview.

The Verdict on Interview Questions

While interview questions may not be perfect, they serve a purpose in the hiring process. They allow employers to assess a candidate's compatibility with the company culture, problem-solving abilities, and critical thinking skills. While technical qualifications are important, companies prioritize hiring individuals who can contribute positively to the workplace.

Candidates should approach interview questions with authenticity, finding a balance between honesty and presenting themselves in the best light. By understanding the rationale behind interview questions and preparing accordingly, job seekers can increase their chances of success in the hiring process.

Noticed an error or an aspect of this article that requires correction? Please provide the article link and reach out to us. We appreciate your feedback and will address the issue promptly.

Check out our latest stories