OOPS! YOU ADDED TOO MUCH: A Humorous Guide to Cookie Fails

Grayson Larkspur

Updated Friday, September 27, 2024 at 12:00 AM CDT

Baking enthusiasts and humor lovers alike, gather around! A recent image circulating on Reddit has taken the internet by storm, showcasing the comically disastrous results of adding too much of specific ingredients when making cookies. The image, titled "The perfect cookie," is a visual guide that humorously exaggerates what happens when baking goes wrong.

At the top of the image, bold text reads "OOPS! YOU ADDED TOO MUCH:", setting the tone for the comical revelations to follow. The image features six cookies, each labeled with a different ingredient that was added in excess.

1. **Butter**: The top-left cookie looks greasy and has spread out unevenly. Its shiny surface and scattered chocolate chips make it appear almost like a puddle of deliciousness. One user commented, "I don't see anything wrong with the 'too much butter' cookies. They look delicious."

2. **Sugar**: The top-right cookie is puffy with an irregular shape and large air pockets. Despite its inflated appearance, it shares a similar shine and chocolate chip distribution as the butter cookie. Another user noted, "The 'too much butter' cookie looks amazing."

3. **Flour**: The middle-left cookie is dry and crumbly with a dull surface. It has less spread and appears thicker, almost like a shortbread gone wrong. This prompted a user to humorously lament, "Turns out I've been making them wrong this whole time! 😔"

4. **Baking Soda**: The middle-right cookie is extremely puffy and airy, with a cracked surface and large air pockets, giving it an uneven texture. This led one commenter to share, "Too much baking soda makes cookies disgusting."

5. **Egg**: The bottom-left cookie looks somewhat similar to the butter cookie but is less greasy. It is slightly puffier and has a more structured shape with evenly distributed chocolate chips.

6. **P******: The bottom-right cookie takes the cake for humor. It has an odd, almost bagel-like shape with a large hole in the middle. The surface looks dry and cracked, with uneven textures. This humorous addition led to multiple comments, including, "Now I'll always be suspicious about donuts," and "Wait so those crumbly donuts are actually p**** cookies?!"

The image not only serves as a funny reminder of the potential pitfalls of baking but also as a light-hearted way to engage with the baking community. One user even joked, "You haven't lived until you've tried one of my homemade cocklate chip cookies! Delicious!"

This Reddit image titled "The perfect cookie" provides a humorous look at what happens when too much of a good thing goes wrong in the kitchen. Whether it's butter, sugar, flour, baking soda, egg, or the unexpected "p****," each exaggerated cookie fail brings a smile and a laugh to anyone who has ever faced a baking mishap. So, the next time cookies are on the menu, remember: moderation is key, and humor is essential!

Noticed an error or an aspect of this article that requires correction? Please provide the article link and reach out to us. We appreciate your feedback and will address the issue promptly.

View source: Reddit

Top Comments from Reddit

bis***h92

I don't see anything wrong with the "too much butter" or "too much sugar" cookies. They look delicious.

KingotWinterCarnival

Well, what's the right amount of p****?

Chillieman16

Now I'll always be suspicious about donuts

Grueaux

The "too much butter" cookie looks amazing.

Sihgilanu

Turns out I've been making them wrong this whole time! 😔

sucobe

This is why I f*** the cookie dough batter. Feels pleasant on the prostate

Slaves2Darkness

Funny I've never added P**** to my cookies.

brasticstack

You haven't lived until you've tried one of my homemeade cocklate chip cookies! Delicious!

fuzzycuffs

JD Vance school of baking

Hoosier_Daddy68

I disagree, it's impossible to add too much butter, sugar or p****.

Check out our latest stories