The Hidden Dynamics of the American Healthcare System

Sofia Rodriguez

Updated Sunday, June 23, 2024 at 2:17 PM CDT

The Hidden Dynamics of the American Healthcare System

The Influence and Constraints of Doctors in Healthcare

Doctors are often perceived as having the collective power to influence insurance costs and the overall quality and cost of healthcare. However, many refrain from leveraging this power due to the risk it poses to their high income. The reality is that the healthcare system's complexity and the need to "play ball" with insurance companies make it difficult for doctors to advocate for systemic changes. Some doctors feel powerless, stating they receive a salary and that decisions are made by hospital owners, such as hedge fund managers. This dynamic creates a situation where the power of individual doctors is overestimated; they are often seen as educated cogs in a machine that can be replaced.

The healthcare industry is dominated by a few large conglomerates that own the majority of American hospitals, making it difficult for doctors to find jobs if they leave. When doctors become problematic or quit, they are often replaced by foreign doctors on work visas who are easier to control. This fear of losing jobs to foreign doctors discourages American doctors from challenging the system, further perpetuating the status quo.

The Role of the American Medical Association

The American Medical Association (AMA) is seen as a guild that protects doctors' high incomes by limiting the number of medical schools and opposing the expansion of non-MD practice scopes. The U.S. has the same number of medical students as France, despite having five times the population, creating an artificial scarcity of doctors. The AMA's opposition to building more medical schools and expanding the scope of practice for non-MDs is seen as a way to maintain a monopoly and high pay.

This artificial scarcity contributes to the high costs of healthcare. The credentialing process for doctors is complex, and they must be part of the system to get paid, as most patients cannot afford to pay for care outright. The healthcare system profits from overcharging for procedures like CAT scans, which have already been paid off multiple times. This overcharging is part of the game hospitals play with insurance companies, charging exorbitant amounts to receive large reimbursements.

The Impact of Medical Malpractice Lawsuits

Attorneys who specialize in medical malpractice contribute to higher healthcare costs as hospitals and doctors take extra precautions to avoid lawsuits. Some medical malpractice lawsuits are viewed as justified, but many are seen as frivolous, driving up costs unnecessarily. This legal landscape adds another layer of complexity to the healthcare system, making it even more challenging for doctors to advocate for meaningful change.

The sentiment that asking doctors to fix the healthcare system is akin to expecting landlords to address the housing crisis underscores the systemic issues at play. The credentialing system forces doctors to participate in the existing healthcare framework, limiting their ability to push for change. Some patients, like those in the ER, experience continuous denial of care from regular doctors and OBs, highlighting systemic issues that need to be addressed.

The Rise of Unionization and Strikes

Despite these challenges, there has been an increase in doctors and nurses organizing, unionizing, and striking, which has been reported in the news. This movement suggests that healthcare professionals are beginning to recognize their collective power and are willing to take risks to advocate for better working conditions and systemic changes. Unionization efforts could potentially shift the balance of power, giving doctors and nurses a stronger voice in the healthcare system.

However, the road to meaningful change is fraught with obstacles. The healthcare industry is a complex web of interests, and any attempt to reform it will require coordinated efforts from multiple stakeholders. While doctors and nurses play a crucial role in this process, they cannot do it alone. Policymakers, insurance companies, and patients must also be part of the conversation to create a more equitable and efficient healthcare system.

The American healthcare system is a complex and multifaceted entity influenced by various stakeholders, including doctors, hospital owners, and the AMA. While doctors have the potential to influence systemic changes, they face significant constraints that limit their ability to do so. The rise of unionization and strikes among healthcare professionals offers a glimmer of hope for meaningful reform, but achieving lasting change will require collective action from all stakeholders involved.

Noticed an error or an aspect of this article that requires correction? Please provide the article link and reach out to us. We appreciate your feedback and will address the issue promptly.

Check out our latest stories